
Just when Mark Thomas Amadei thought the troubles were over at Delicatessen, his recently opened Nolita restaurant, the New York Observer has just deemed it "undeniably the city’s most loathed new restaurant in 2008."
Since opening in July, the establishment has faced critical pans, trouble from its neighbors and, just last month, two robberies.
"It's certainly not the start we had hoped for," Amadei said. "Sometimes, people don’t like change and, you know, I totally get that.” Amadei opened the trendy, faux deli on the site of Buffa’s Coffee Shop, an historic Nolita family-run coffee shop which closed at 4:30 p.m. and stayed shut on weekends.
After a slew of negative reviews (the restaurant was awarded zero stars by both the New York Times and
The noise became such a problem that one upset neighbor took to urinating on the building's glass roof.
“I know not everyone is happy with Delicatessen but, please stop urinating on the glass roof. I have to buy a new a/c because you did not aim correctly! Thank you!” wrote one neighbor posted in the adjacent apartment building’s hallway that was later republished in the New York Post.
In another incident a few weeks later, several residents dumped buckets of water on patrons waiting outside for a table.
"They play this pounding trance music late into the night," said Cindy Huh, a resident of the adjacent apartment building at
In November, Delicatessen was burglarized two times. The second time, the thieves entered posing as construction workers and took off with a laptop and some smaller items, Amadei said.
Despite the mounting troubles, Amadei said he was optimistic and faced similar issues 10 years ago when he opened up the
"Neighbors hates us when we opened; critics panned us," he said. "But, you know, we turned out all right, and I think the same can happen here, too."